Who Won the Shutdown Showdown? It Wasn't Even Close Says Carl Cameron - Budget Battle - Fox Nation
Politics

April 11, 2011

Who Won the Shutdown Showdown? It Wasn't Even Close Says Carl Cameron

AP Graphic

By Carl Cameron, Fox News

While Republicans wanted to cut more spending in Saturday's early morning compromise to keep the government open, they think they got the better of the deal.

Here's why: HR1 was originally to seek spending cuts of $32 billion until Tea Party conservatives insisted on more than $ 60 billion. House Speaker John Boehner won more cuts than he originally sought and got the Senate to agree to votes to defund the health care reform law and groups like the nation's largest abortion provider Planned Parenthood - once votes Senate Majority leader Harry Reid said he'd never allow to come to the floor.Back on February 3, Reid called $32 billion in cuts "extreme" and "draconian."

At a news conference New York Sen. Chuck Schumer, D-N.Y., agreed, "I happen to think some of their cuts are extreme and go overboard. But every week they keep upping the ante and proposing extreme cuts."

Over the next decade the cuts are expected to save hundreds of billions of dollars.

The deal mandates a host of studies and audits of Obama administration policies. It also blocks additional funds for the IRS sought by the Obama administration and bans federal funding of abortion in Washington, D.C.

The history of offers on this bill goes something like this. Democrats first offered no cuts, then $4 billion, then $6.5 billion, then $33 billion, then settled at $38.5 billion.

Boehner made numerous adjustments to his offer in recent days too, but started at $32 billion, then with a Tea Party push went to $62 billion, then dropped to $40 billion, then $38.5 billion.

Democrats claimed they met Republicans halfway after the $10 billion in cuts that already passed this year were approved. They settled late Friday night at three and a half times more.

Boehner came in $8.5 billion higher than the halfway point between his high offer of $61 billion in cuts and the Democrats opening bid of zero cuts.

Read the full story at foxnews.com

What do you think?


Comments

All Opinions Welcome

The Fox Nation is for those opposed to intolerance, excessive government control of our lives, and attempts to monopolize opinion or suppress freedom of thought, expression, and worship. Read more...

We invite all Americans who share these values to join us here at Fox Nation.

Subscribe to the Newsletter

President Barack Obama holds up a Los Angeles Galaxy soccer jersey as he stands with David Beckham, during a ceremony at the White House in Washington, Tuesday, May 15, 2012, where he...

Sen. Rob Portman on President Obama

"He will have to explain to the American people why his vision for bigger government, more spending, and higher taxes will work over the next four years when it hasn't worked in the past three and a half years.” – Sen. Rob Portman on President Obama

 

By Justin FishelPublished May 16, 2012 | FoxNews.comIt was May 10, 1970, in Se San, Cambodia. Spc. Leslie H. Sabo Jr. and his platoon were ambushed by a large enemy force. The 22-year-old rifleman...

Twitter Brigade

politico: Manny Pacquiao insists he has nothing against gay people -- but still believes they shouldn’t be allowed to marry: http://t.co/vktw6DQi

dloesch: @EvanPokroy I'll take your word for it. Looks like Fancy Feast though. @gregb94

washingtonpost: Obama warns Republicans that he won't tolerate another debt ceiling fight: http://t.co/x3KoBxGj

foxbusiness: Windows gets a clean sweep: Microsoft's new Signature models easier to navigate, more streamlined http://t.co/tutql1lK

postpolitics: On the debt ceiling, student loans and ‘fake fights’ http://t.co/MWI3NClb