Faith's attempts to get law enforcement to look at her evidence gets a boost with a U.S. Supreme Court decision, and a new review of the Girl Scout Murders is set to begin. But she finds that her journey into this tragedy is far from over.

Oklahoma author Faith Phillips discovers new details about who may have committed the Girl Scout Murders. When she tries to give her findings to local law enforcement, she runs into a series of brick walls as police insist the original suspect was guilty.

After a 10-month manhunt, suspect Gene Leroy Hart is captured alive and a controversial trial leaves more questions than answers. But 45 years later, the possibility of answers arises when a local author makes an unexpected discovery.

In June, 1977, two busloads of Girl Scouts from Tulsa arrived in the woods of the nearby Cherokee reservation. But their first night there turns to horror when three of the young girls, ages 8, 9, and 10, are discovered brutally beaten and murdered.